When "peer comments" etc. are hidden because of rule violation... دھاگا پوسٹ کرنے والے: Cilian O'Tuama
|
|---|
When "peer comments" etc. are hidden because of rule violation, it would be more productive IMO if only the actual comment were removed, and the agree/neutral/disagree remained visible.
Cilian
| | | | Eva T
البانیائیسےانگریزی
+ ...
| I agree with that | Apr 12, 2010 |
I actually agree with this: the agree/disagree should still be in place.
Thanks,
Eva
| | | | | The rating and the comment together form the peer comment, as a whole unit | Apr 12, 2010 |
Hello Cilian,
Thanks for the suggestion. I just wanted to point out that a peer comment is composed of a rating (agree/disagree/neutral) and a comment. The comment has to back the rating with a linguistic reason.
The rating and the comment together form the peer comment, as a whole unit. Please note that peer comments must be based on linguistic considerations and said considerations must be provided in case of disagree or neutral comments.
Please let me kn... See more Hello Cilian,
Thanks for the suggestion. I just wanted to point out that a peer comment is composed of a rating (agree/disagree/neutral) and a comment. The comment has to back the rating with a linguistic reason.
The rating and the comment together form the peer comment, as a whole unit. Please note that peer comments must be based on linguistic considerations and said considerations must be provided in case of disagree or neutral comments.
Please let me know if you have any doubts.
Regards,
Alejandro ▲ Collapse
| | | | Henry Hinds 
امریکہ
Local time: 04:58
اسپینیسےانگریزی
+ ...
میموریم میں | Rating without a comment? | Apr 12, 2010 |
"A rating without a comment to back it up would not only be of little help, but it would be against KudoZ peer commenting rule #5."
Then it looks like the vast majority of ratings are in violation because they contain no comment, just the rating.
Do you care to comment on that?
| | |
|
|
|
Cilian O'Tuama
جرمنی
Local time: 12:58
انگریزیسےجرمن
+ ...
TOPIC STARTER | Thanks, Alejandro, but... | Apr 12, 2010 |
Alejandro Cavalitto wrote:
The rating and the comment together form the peer comment, as a whole unit.
Well, maybe a solution would be to decouple them. Can't be that difficult.
Alejandro Cavalitto wrote:
A rating without a comment to back it up would not only be of little help, but it would be against rule #5, which states that peer comments must be backed by linguistic reasons.
Well, it's possible to agree without commenting.
But that's all beside my point. I just feel the recent increase in moderator intervention has distorted the scoring system and is not doing anything in the way of helping askers. On the contrary.
Cilian
| | | | Mihai Badea (X)
لکزمبرگ
رومانیائیسےانگریزی
+ ...
| I would keep things as they are | Apr 12, 2010 |
I think there are rare instances where agree comments are removed. I can imagine, for instance, ironical agrees being removed. Disagree comments are removed when they are not of a linguistic nature. And if the disagree was given based on reasons other than linguistic, why should the disagree stay after the comment violating the rules is deleted? As to the neutral grades, they become meaningless after the comments are removed.
| | | | | Only "Neutral" or "Disagree" peer comments require comments | Apr 12, 2010 |
Hello Henry, Cilian,
Thanks for your replies. My first comment was not fully accurate. I have now edited it to reflect the description of peer comments on http://www.proz.com/faq/4876#4876 .
Only "Neutral" and "Disagree" peer comments require comments, "Agree" comment do not.
Best regards,
Alejandro
| | | | Monika Coulson
Local time: 04:58
رکن (2001)
البانیائیسےانگریزی
+ ...
SITE LOCALIZER | Allowing peers to re-grade again | Apr 12, 2010 |
I agree that when the non-appropriate comment has been removed, the rating has to go too. However, the peer should be given another chance of rating the same question. AFAIK, once a comment has been removed, the peer is no longer allowed to rate that particular question.
Putting back the option of rating for that question (allowing the peer to re-grade) could be a solution.
Monika
| | |
|
|
|
Cilian O'Tuama
جرمنی
Local time: 12:58
انگریزیسےجرمن
+ ...
TOPIC STARTER
Mihai Badea wrote:
I think there are rare instances ...
Hi Mihai,
Maybe they're rare in your language pairs; they're all too frequent in mine.
Alejandro wrote:
I have now edited it...
That's great.
Now, have you a comment to make on my posting?
Thanks
Cilian
| | | | Cilian O'Tuama
جرمنی
Local time: 12:58
انگریزیسےجرمن
+ ...
TOPIC STARTER | That's worth considering | Apr 12, 2010 |
Monika Coulson wrote:
I agree that when the non-appropriate comment has been removed, the rating has to go too. However, the peer should be given another chance of rating the same question.
...
Putting back the option of rating for that question (allowing the peer to re-grade) could be a solution.
Monika
Thanks Monika for your constructive suggestion. Either sth. like that, or the comment is only temporarily hidden and the poster given the chance to edit it to within the rulez.
Cilian
| | | | To report site rules violations or get help, contact a site moderator: You can also contact site staff by submitting a support request » When "peer comments" etc. are hidden because of rule violation... | Pastey | Your smart companion app
Pastey is an innovative desktop application that bridges the gap between human expertise and artificial intelligence. With intuitive keyboard shortcuts, Pastey transforms your source text into AI-powered draft translations.
Find out more » |
| | Trados Studio 2022 Freelance | The leading translation software used by over 270,000 translators.
Designed with your feedback in mind, Trados Studio 2022 delivers an unrivalled, powerful desktop
and cloud solution, empowering you to work in the most efficient and cost-effective way.
More info » |
|
| | | | X Sign in to your ProZ.com account... | | | | | |
Login to reply/comment 
